After 16 months of heated public debate, New Plymouth District councillors have voted 10–5 to remove the controversial concrete cycleway barriers along Devon Street West.
Taranaki Media watched the entirety of the extraordinary council meeting, which stretched for more than four hours as elected members weighed the future of the separators, otherwise known locally as "Tim Tams".
The decision delivers on a major 2025 mayoral election campaign promise from Mayor Max Brough and aligns with the wishes of a strong majority of residents and business owners. Subject to approval from NZTA, crews will remove the concrete blocks between Morley Street and Belair Avenue and replace them with a painted cycle lane. While the physical work will not be finished before Christmas, the council plans to complete the removal over the Christmas school holidays.
Summing up his argument for the removal, Mayor Brough noted the original installation had not been born out of a genuine request by New Plymouth residents. Instead, he stated the idea had germinated in Wellington, noting an overwhelming majority of locals had never asked for the barriers and had continually called for them to be taken out.
Despite fulfilling a campaign promise Brough avoided framing the result as a personal political victory. "I didn't come here to make a big shout about how good I feel. I came here to do some stuff round town for people and this is just one part of many," he said.
The financial cost of the reversal is set at a fixed $300,000 to remove the separators and repaint the road markings. Chief executive Kelvin Wright confirmed the funds can be found within existing council budgets, achieved in part by continuing to hold off on filling already unoccupied staff positions.
NPDC’s decision to remove the cycle separators, makes it the second council alongside the Tasman district Council to remove the separators during the past two years.
During the four-hour session, councillors pressed senior officer Sarah Downs for empirical data from the recent trial of alternative separators before casting their votes, though she struggled to provide conclusive evidence.
Councillor Murray Chong took the floor to present his own findings, sharing insights from over a hundred hours of effort collating video footage from the corridor, alongside tallying reports of tyre damage and accidents caused by the Tim Tams from local mechanics and tyre repair shops.
Other councillors echoed the frustration of the community during the debate. Councillor Damon Fox stated that voting against the removal would send a message of "we believe we know better than the people who put us here."
Meanwhile, Councillor Graham Chard referenced the famous phrase, "Build it and they will come," before adding, "Well we built it and they did not come."
Councillor Gordon Brown referred to the installation as a "social experiment delivered under the guise of safety", and further added that property values of those along the Devon Street corridor had been affected.
Councillor EJ Barrett held a different perspective, stating there were multiple young families who had moved to Devon Street to be near the schools since the separators had been installed. Cr Barrett argued that the removal of the separators would result in people not feeling safe enough to cycle around the city and would force them into car ownership in times of economic difficulty.
Earlier in the meeting, local businessman Shane Devlin, who helped organise a 7,500-signature petition opposing the original layout, welcomed the move to clear the street. "This should've been done a year ago. It's terrible it's carried on this long, but at least we've got some common-sense and we can move forward and get our street back again," Devlin said, adding he was not overly concerned about the cost to ratepayers.
Councillor David Bublitz, who served as deputy mayor when the cycleway was developed, attempted to tie the removal decision to reinstating lost car parks through the Long-Term Plan. While his amendment was ruled out of order, the council will still investigate restoring some parking through future planning processes, keeping national road rules on safe passing distances in mind.
How they voted:
For removal (10):
Mayor Max Brough, Cr Damon Fox, Cr Sam Bennett, Cr Murray Chong, Cr Kerry Vosseler, Cr Moira George, Cr Graham Chard, Cr Gordon Brown, Cr John Woodward, and Cr Christine Fabish
Against removal (5):
Cr Gina Blackburn, Cr Dinnie Moeahu, Cr David Bublitz, Cr EJ Barrett, and Cr Te Waka McLeod.
What do you make of the council's decision to remove the Tim Tams over the holidays? Let us know in the comments below.
PHOTO CREDIT: Shane Devlin (GRAPHIX Design).










