Taranaki's most impressive police investigation: The Birgit Brauer murder
In 2005 Phil Quinney, John Blackman and myself were part of the Taranaki Newstalk ZB regional news team. And like the Taranaki Daily News were covered this story. And we all came to respect Detective Senior Sergeant Grant Coward who led the investigation.
So if I had to nominate one investigation in Taranaki's history, it would be Operation Lucy – the 2005 murder investigation into German backpacker Birgit Brauer.
It was an extraordinary piece of detective work involving an international tourist, a missing-person investigation that became a murder inquiry, extensive searches of the Taranaki countryside and a determined effort to identify and catch her killer.
What makes it particularly impressive is that detectives eventually solved a case that initially appeared to offer very few clues.
What happened?
On 20 September 2005, 28-year-old Birgit Brauer, from Dresden, Germany, was hitchhiking from Whanganui towards New Plymouth.
She was picked up near Waitōtara. Her body was discovered later that day by a jogger at Lucy's Gully, near Ōakura. She had suffered horrific head injuries and a stab wound to the chest.
Detective Senior Sergeant Grant Coward led the investigation.
Why was the investigation so impressive?
There were several outstanding aspects:
1. Reconstructing her final journey: Detectives pieced together sightings of Birgit and a dark four-wheel-drive vehicle across Taranaki and further north.
2. The Lake Rotokare breakthrough: On 3 October, police discovered her two backpacks concealed in bush beside Lake Rotokare. Public information about a vehicle seen at the reserve helped direct the search.
3. A nationwide manhunt: Police identified Michael Scott Wallace as a person they wanted to question and issued a nationwide appeal. The public supplied a huge volume of information.
4. The arrest: On 8 October, Wallace was apprehended at Sanson, near Feilding, in a stolen Nissan four-wheel-drive.
5. Forensic evidence: Fingerprint and DNA evidence, combined with witness sightings and other circumstantial evidence, helped secure the prosecution.
The outcome
Conviction secured
In 2007, Wallace was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum non-parole period of 18 years. His appeal against conviction and sentence was subsequently dismissed.
Former detective Grant Coward received the Commissioner's Silver Merit Award in 2008 for his role in the investigation.
In my opinion, Operation Lucy deserves serious consideration as Taranaki's most impressive murder investigation. It demonstrated the importance of painstaking detective work, forensic science, public cooperation and coordination between police districts.










